Controversy at Robert Morris

The whole story here is kind of, well, kind of crazy. There. I said it.

A Chicago dance team that performed in straitjackets last month has drawn criticism from a mental health advocate who said the outfits displayed insensitivity toward people with mental disorders.

The Robert Morris University competitive dance team wore the costumes, which included wild, frizzy hair and dark eye makeup, at a national contest in Minnesota. Chrisa Hickey, a Barrington mother whose 16-year-old son has schizoaffective disorder, complained to the school after she saw an online photo of the dancers last week.

“It’s accepted as entertainment,” she said. “But if you’ve seen your kid restrained and medicated because he’s having a complete psychotic break, it wouldn’t be entertaining.”

Robert Morris President Michael Viollt said the costumes were inappropriate and will not be worn again. Outfits for the dance team, which until now have not been approved by the school, will go through the same committee that approves the uniforms of sports teams, he said.

I don’t mind the complaint, really; I even sympathize with it. It’s the President’s response that strikes me as ridiculous and particularly weak.

When it comes to art and “offense,” I would say the appropriate response is something like, “What would you propose that we do?” followed by thoughtful discussion about how to take the opportunity to make the moment a teachable one for those involved. The goal would be to make sure that if and when they decide to do something with straightjackets, they are aware of all of the possible implications and interpretations (i.e., be aware of their own blind spots), to help them expand their moral imaginations and so help them develop as artists and people, rather than think a vague criterion like “inappropriate” and a committee process will do the same thing.

Then again, that might just be the do-gooder in me. I’m guessing that MathArt’s response would have been something like re-staging the performance in the Barrington mall. I have some sympathies with that approach, too, to be honest.

2 thoughts on “Controversy at Robert Morris

  1. from a response to a comment on her blog, chrisa hickey on whether the robert morris dance team’s performance was art:
    “…I don’t see high school and college dance/cheer teams as “art”.”

    regarding straight jacket dancing, what happens when

    ballerinas do it subtly:

    it happens in a basketball court in texas, but it’s called modern dance:

    in bloomers, to pop music:

    it’s lit well:

    it’s funded and produced well:

    • either way, ms. hickey is responding to an offensive, insensitive picture, not to a dance routine specifically. the routine isn’t online anywhere that i can tell, she wasn’t at the performance in minnesota and i don’t think it was described to her in detail as she doesn’t mention its music or choreography or really anything other than it’s costuming in the letter she wrote to robert morris college (posted on her blog). there’s a good chance she’s right, but it seems pretty unfair for her to chalk the team up to a superficial cheer squad without anything but a picture of them in stage makeup to work with.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s